Can't all insect behavior be predicted by a predetermined algorithm, no different than a computer program?
Many people believe that insects can not possibly be conscious because all insect behavior can be predicted by a computer program.
In spite of the fact that insects are able to learn from past experience, and in spite of the fact that the social complexity of some insects rivals that of most human societies, it is true that to the best of our current knowledge, all insect behavior can be simulated by a computer program.
However, this does not imply that insects lack consciousness. After all, it might also be possible to simulate all human behavior with a computer algorithm. The algorithm for simulating human behavior would be far more complex than the algorithm for insect behavior, and it would have to take into account all the life experiences the person has had. Although the computer necessary to run such a complex program is well beyond our current technological abilities, this does not imply that it is not possible to do in principle.
In particular, the conclusion that this task is possible is the logically inescapable view for atheists who believe that human consciousness is entirely the result of complex electrochemical reactions in the brain (in other words - for people who believe that humans do not possess a soul).
This is because the behavior of all atoms and molecules is understandable through the known laws of physics. Therefore, all behavior of physical systems composed of atoms and molecules can, in principle, be simulated by a computer program. If human beings are just physical systems composed of atoms and molecules, then all our behavior can also, in principle, be simulated by a computer program as well.
Follow up questions:
Don't insects only behave on an instinctual level?
What do you do when a colony of insects infests your home?
Do you view the killing of an insect as the moral equivalent of killing a bird or mammal?
Back to the title page
Back to the list of the most commonly asked questions